Leaders' debate: Nicola Sturgeon surges to victory in historic TV showdown
The First Minister of Scotland Nicola Sturgeon secured a major pre-election victory by winning the TV leaders' debate tonight.
An average of three snap surveys (ICM, YouGov and ComRes) after the two-hour long debate in Salford showed that the SNP leader had beaten David Cameron to poll position (22% vs 21%).
The research also revealed that Labour leader Ed Miliband and Ukip firebrand Nigel Farage drew for third place as both garnered 20% of the vote.
The historic seven-way showdown came after a 90-minute question and answer session on Sky News and Channel 4, when Miliband and Cameron were grilled by legendary political inquisitor Jeremy Paxman.
But Miliband failed to sink his teeth into the prime minister during tonight's contest as the leaders scrapped for air time.
Farage probably offered the most controversial remarks of the night when he said foreign HIV positive patients should not use the NHS to source expensive antiviral drugs from the NHS.
Plaid Cymru Leanne Wood hit out at Farage over the comment and claimed he "should be ashamed of himself".
"This kind of scaremongering rhetoric is dangerous. It divides communities and it creates stigma to people who are ill and I think you should be ashamed of yourself," she argued.
The debate also hotted up when a heckler, Victoria Prosser, attacked David Cameron over the issue of homeless veterans.
The 33-year-old was reportedly removed from the ITV studio in Salford after the outburst. She later told journalists that she wanted to question the "1% at the top" of British society, "who are not working in our best interests".
But another poll from ICM has put Miliband in first place.
ICM poll #leadersdebate Miliband 25% Cameron 24% Farage 19% Sturgeon 17% Clegg 9% Bennett 3% Wood 2%
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
YouGov have called it for Sturgeon, who had a eight point lead over Farage straight after the debate in a snap poll.
Debate Result: Sturgeon wins Cameron: 18% Miliband: 15% Clegg: 10% Farage: 20% Bennett: 5% Sturgeon: 28% Wood: 4% 1117 GB adults
— YouGov (@YouGov) April 2, 2015
The leaders have now made their closing remarks. Bennett told people to vote "for what you believe in" and warned not to "vote for lesser of two evils".
Wood kept with her anti-austerity theme and claimed for a stronger Wales, "give your vote to Plaid Cymru".
Miliband stressed that he would work hard for everybody and stop tax avoidance, while cutting the deficit every year he is in power.
Liberal Democrat leader Clegg repeated that his party would not allow a future government to "lurch" to the left or right. "When you vote, vote to keep country stable, strong and fair," he urged.
Sturgeon, meanwhile, kept it simple. She said for a "louder voice in Scotland" vote for the SNP.
Farage: for proper change you must put more Ukip MPs in Westminster. Let's do it #leadersdebate
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
DC: want to finish job started. Halved deficit, lets get in black. Genuine 7-day NHS. Security for family, you and country #leadersdebate — IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
We've got our first heckle of the night. Homeless servicemen and fracking appeared to be her gripes. The woman has been reportedly removed from the studio.
Cameron gets heckled by woman in the audience, who 'has to speak out' #LeadersDebate https://t.co/3GTxT8peim
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 2, 2015
Sturgeon: none of these men can be trusted on tuition fees. Calls Clegg "shameful" #leadersdebate
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
The debate has now moved onto young people what the parties would do to make youngsters feel optimistic.
Wood says Plaid Cymru want to offer free tuition fees , but claims because of austerity the party can't.
Miliband, however, says he will help out be abolishing exploitative zero-hours contracts.
Cameron, meanwhile, argues that his government's Help to Buy will help young people get on the property ladder and the prime minister stressed that a Tory government would create an extra two million jobs.
Elsewhere, Bennett argues that education is a public good and should be paid for by progressive taxation.
Clegg, who infamously broke his pledge on cutting tuition fees, blames Labour for "jacking up" the fees.
Sturgeon, who explains she is from a working-class background, argues that she will always fight to university fee.
Finally, Farage argues that the social mobility gap is increasing and the decision to move away from grammar schools has hurt those looking to climb the education and jobs ladder.
Farage finds an unlikely ally in Wood on his immigration point.
Wood: Farage right when he says you can't control immigration as part of EU #leadersdebate
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
A snap poll from ComRes showed that Farage was ahead of the other six party leaders at half-time. Can the Eurosceptic maintain his lead for another hour?
ComRes: Farage 22% Bennett 21% Wood 18% Cameron 17% Miliband 10% Clegg 7% Sturgeon 6%
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
Ouch! The two right-wing leaders have just had a scrap. Farage claims that the German Chancellor Angela Merkel is "the real boss in the EU" and states you cannot renegotiate free movement of people.
Cameron, however, said Farage is "just a back to Labour, which will give us an open door to immigration".
. @nick_clegg argues that the UK should remain open hearted about immigration #LeadersDebate https://t.co/sH7pb4IiW9
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 2, 2015
On the issue, Sturgeon says we need to "recognise that there is a strain on housing and public services"; Wood argues "we should not allow rhetoric that blames immigration for ills" and Miliband says his government would "offer control" but not cut the UK off from the rest of the world.
DC: immigration has been very high. Proposals: if EU won't get unemployment benefit. Sent home is no job after 6 months #leadersdebate
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
Farage: we have total open door to 10 former Communist countries. We have to build new house every 7mins to cope #leadersdebate — IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
ITV have gone to a short break. Up next is immigration. We're sure one of the leaders will attack Cameron over his failed pledge to reduce net migration to the UK to less than 100,000.
Bennett: 800k elderly not getting any social care at all. #leadersdebate
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
Midland and Cameron are now locked together in a head-to-head over the NHS.
The Labour leader claimed the Health and Social Care Act was a "recipe for privatisation" and if you slash social care, you "undermine" the NHS fundamentally.
But the Tory leader hit back. He argued that Miliband was "scaremongering" and mentioned the Mid-Staffordshire Hospital scandal, which happened under Labour.
Bennett argues that the Coalition Government have privatised the NHS and the act has caused "huge damage". "We are racing towards an American system," the Green leader argues.
Farage, however, repeats his point that health tourism is costing the UK too much.
The Ukip leader says there are 7,000 diagnoses each year for HIV. 60% are not British nationals and drugs costs £25,000 a year, he claims.
Farage argues that health tourism costs the UK £2bn a year and declares that foreign workers should have health insurance.
Miliband, meanwhile, attacks the prime minister over Accident and Emergency waiting times, citing official data that shows his government have missed their targets.
Elsewhere, Clegg says the question is simple: "who has a plan to put an extra £8bn in to NHS?". The Liberal Democrat leader says you are only going to get if you ask the wealthy to pay more.
Sturgeon: not anything Farage would not blame on foreigners. Modest spending increases would add to NHS and not cut welfare #leadersdebate
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
Cameron shares personal story of his visits to NHS services with his late son #LeadersDebate https://t.co/skV7MfoHX8
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 2, 2015
Clegg: we all love NHS. But it needs hard cash: £8bn by 2020. #leadersdebate
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
Farage claims the UK could make massive savings if it left the EU #LeadersDebate https://t.co/XCJHUspWo9
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 2, 2015
Miliband is now attacking Cameron over his so called "bedroom tax", otherwise know as the spare room subsidy.
EM: DC refuses mansion tax, chooses to keep bedroom tax. #leadersdebate
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
Cameron promises to eliminate the UK's deficit and run a surplus by the end of the next parliament.
DC shows letter reminding viewers there was no money left when he arrived at NO. 10 #leadersdebate
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
Wood struggles to make her point as it heats up in Salford #LeadersDebate https://t.co/Xqq4XXA1Uo
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 2, 2015
It seems it's heating up in Salford. Farage had his say about public spending:
Farage: spending got out of control under Labour but we have doubled national debt. We have a massive problem #leadersdebate
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
There seemed to be some clear water between the party leaders on public sector cuts. Sturgeon attacked the Tories, Labour and the Liberal Democrats over the issue.
Sturgeon attacks Tories, Lib Dems and Labour over cuts #leadersdebate https://t.co/3YBaUvcp3H
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 2, 2015
Finally, Wood makes her case to the British public.
Leanne Wood: Support Plaid Cymru to make our communities in Wales stronger #leadersdebate
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
Elsewhere, Miliband argues that for five years wages have not kept up with bills and the NHS has "gone backwards". He repeats his pledge to hike the minimum wage to £8 per hour.
Cameron delivers his opening statement:
Cameron: UK was on brink. LTE plan working. Invested in NHS, cut taxes for 30m. The choice is sticking with plan that works or back to mess
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 2, 2015
With only minutes to go before the big debate kicks off, here's our 60 second take on what you need to know about the 2015 general election.
ITV are predicting that they could get a staggering 10 million viewers for tonight's debate. The first 2010 general election TV debate garnered 9.4 million, so it's certainly not a pipe-dream. But will the extra number of politicians – and rhetoric – turn people off?
ITV predicting as many as 10m viewers-even if nothing like that,what happens tonight will affect momentum of parties + that matters too
— Laura Kuenssberg (@bbclaurak) April 2, 2015
Miliband was on good form yesterday when he revealed to Absolute Radio that he was a big Manic Miner player. The interview was a bit of a nostalgia trip and the Labour leader seemed relaxed and cheerful. He will definitely want to carry that momentum into tonight's debate.
No doubt the leaders have done lots and lots of preparation before tonight's event.
The Greens told IBTimes UK that Bennett has been revising ahead of the debate, but they wouldn't go into specifics.
Nigel Farage, meanwhile, may enjoy a "big gin" before the showdown, a senior source close to the Ukip leader told IBTimes UK.
Elsewhere, Clegg is "just catching up on a few stats and figures". Or is that Lord Ashcroft's Sheffield Hallam poll?
Just catching up on a few stats and figures before the #leadersdebate tonight. #StrongerEconomy #FairerSociety. pic.twitter.com/JQuT7zQoZr
— Nick Clegg (@nick_clegg) April 2, 2015
It all kicks off at 8pm and here's the speaking order. It looks like Cameron has an advantage by speaking last. But look out Dave, Farage will be hot on your heels.
Great analysis by @May2015NS on the running order for Thursday's ITV event http://t.co/Aa6jBAUPVd pic.twitter.com/H4MIwiGAX1 #GE2015 #TVdebates
— NumbrCrunchrPolitics (@NCPoliticsUK) March 31, 2015
© Copyright IBTimes 2024. All rights reserved.