'I feel robbed': Shark Week viewers miffed that Michael Phelps did not actually race a shark
Discovery promoted the premiere episode with claims that the US Olympic swimmer would swim against a great white shark.
Michael Phelps is a US national treasure, so when Discovery claimed he would be racing a great white shark for the premiere of Shark Week, they clearly did not mean to put the 23-time gold winner in a pool with one of the most dangerous predators in the world. For Phelps vs Shark: Great Gold vs Great White, the channel instead placed a digitally rendered shark next to swimmer to simulate the "race" based on records taken with an actual shark.
"Clearly, we can't put Michael in one lane and a white shark on the far lane. We're gonna have to do a simulation," ecologist Tristan Gutteridge said at one point in the special.
Phelps himself made it clear that he would not be putting his life at risk for TV rating by getting into a pool with a shark, but this did not stop viewers from being disappointed that the whole showdown was digital.
The Shark after beating Phelps #PhelpsVsShark pic.twitter.com/9qoeBbRsqf
— TMK (@tkronski9) July 24, 2017
America's collective disappointment when we realized that #PhelpsVsShark is all just science and simulations: pic.twitter.com/bTww7dAWm3
— Lindsey Barr (@simply_lindsey) July 24, 2017
When the sharks are equally disappointed by the fake hype #PhelpsVsShark #SharkWeek pic.twitter.com/bkSpw2fuda
— Sarah DeWeese (@teensy_deweese) July 24, 2017
Hey @Discovery couldn't you guys film a real race at @SeaWorld with dividers?? You kind of lied to all of us. #PhelpsVsShark
— Benny Aight (@benaydt) July 24, 2017
Call me crazy but I thought they were gonna put Phelps up against a real shark not a simulation. I feel robbed. #SharkWeek #PhelpsVsShark pic.twitter.com/XgdEphkl6m
— Meg Conley (@MegDownSouth) July 24, 2017
I honestly feel so robbed that I just watched an hour of a stupid show to see Michael Phelps race a FAKE shark. #fakenews
— Hannah Bowen (@HannahGBowen) July 24, 2017
Michael Phelps race against a computer generated shark will go down as one of TV's most hyped flops. #gullibleTVviewers
— PhantomAcct (@phantomacct) July 24, 2017
i spent 60 minutes of my life watching a build up to michael phelps race a fake computer generated shark. i'm pissed
— spo (@spoyourboat) July 24, 2017
As for the results of the simulated competition, Phelps was unable to beat one of the ocean's fastest swimmers... but not by much. The great white covered 100 metres in 36.1 seconds while the athlete swam the same distance in 38.1 seconds. The results are still pretty impressive considering that great whites can swim at speeds up to 25mph while the 32-year-old manages a maximum of 6mph.
The swimmer was also made to "race" a reef shark and a hammerhead across 50 metres. He won against the first, with a time of 18.7 seconds but the hammerhead out-swam him with a time of 15.1 seconds.
The moment of glory for #TeamShark!!! #PhelpsVsShark #SharkWeek pic.twitter.com/NWYp1CwiRa
— Shark Week (@SharkWeek) July 24, 2017
© Copyright IBTimes 2025. All rights reserved.