Italian Transgender Ex-Politician Recalls Parliament Bathroom Ban As Sarah McBride Faces Similar Fight

Despite deadly conflicts in Ukraine and the Middle East and a possible trade war with China, US lawmakers still have time to argue about which toilet they are supposed to use.

In a striking reminder of the enduring challenges faced by transgender politicians, Vladimir Luxuria, the first transgender parliamentarian in Europe, has voiced her support for newly elected U.S. Congresswoman Sarah McBride. Luxuria compared her own battle over restroom access in Italy's Parliament to the political firestorm currently engulfing McBride in the United States.

Sarah McBride's Historic Election Sparks Controversy

Sarah McBride, a Democrat from Delaware, made history as the first openly transgender person elected to the U.S. Congress. However, her groundbreaking achievement has been met with backlash. Republican Representative Nancy Mace of South Carolina introduced a resolution mandating that members and staff of the U.S. House of Representatives use restrooms corresponding to their biological sex.

Mace explicitly linked her proposal to McBride's election, stating, "I'm absolutely 100% gonna stand in the way of any man who wants to be in a women's restroom." House Speaker Mike Johnson expressed his support for the resolution, further fuelling the controversy.

McBride responded diplomatically, urging lawmakers to follow the example of everyday Americans who respectfully engage with individuals from diverse backgrounds. "I hope members of Congress can muster that same kindness," she posted on social media.

Luxuria's Parallel Struggle

Vladimir Luxuria, a trailblazer for transgender rights, served in Italy's Chamber of Deputies from 2006 to 2008. She recounted her experience of being barred from using the women's restroom, a scenario strikingly similar to McBride's current predicament.

"They did that to me," Luxuria said, recalling an incident where Elisabetta Gardini, a legislator and ally of then-Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, publicly confronted her outside the women's toilet. "Gardini began yelling at me, 'What were you doing in here? You're a man!'"

Luxuria stood her ground, responding, "If you don't want to see me here, you should go use the men's toilet." The matter escalated into a parliamentary debate, which ultimately allowed Luxuria to use the women's facilities. However, the public spectacle was deeply humiliating.

Reflecting on McBride's situation, Luxuria said, "The purpose here is to generate hate for political purposes. I am very sympathetic to Sarah McBride."

A Longstanding Debate

The debate over restroom access for transgender individuals is not new. Proponents argue for inclusivity and human rights, while opponents voice concerns about safety and privacy in women-only spaces. The issue has sparked polarising debates globally.

In Scotland, public outrage erupted over Isla Bryson, a transgender individual convicted of rape, initially being housed in a women's prison before being transferred to a male facility. These cases exemplify the complexities of balancing individual rights with broader societal concerns.

The challenges faced by transgender politicians extend beyond restrooms. Luxuria's experiences align with those of other trailblazers like Georgina Beyer, the world's first openly transgender member of parliament in New Zealand, and Anna Grodzka of Poland. Both faced verbal abuse and attempts to undermine their legitimacy as lawmakers.

In Poland, Grodzka endured relentless misgendering and derogatory remarks from conservative lawmakers. Similarly, Beyer faced invasive questions about her gender identity, highlighting the persistent scrutiny faced by transgender public figures.

Despite these challenges, transgender politicians like McBride, Luxuria, and others continue to push boundaries and advocate for equality. Luxuria remains steadfast in her belief that such battles are politically motivated distractions. "This is not about restrooms. This is about generating division," she said.