Question Time special: David Cameron beats Ed Miliband in final TV showdown
David Cameron has won what could be a crucial pre-election victory after a snap poll showed that the prime minister came out on top of the Question Time leaders' special.
The Tory leader faced tough questions over his pledge to cut net migration to less than 100,000 in the UK and his promise to hold a referendum on Britain's membership of the EU in 2017.
The event, hosted in Leeds Town Hall and chaired by veteran presenter David Dimbleby, saw a lively audience fire hard questions at the prime minister.
At one point, the prime minister pulled out a copy of the infamous Liam Byrne note, which the former Treasury secretary left Cameron's government after Gordon Brown was kicked out of office in 2010. The Labour man had written that "there was no money left" in the Treasury's coffers.
The stunt and Cameron's other comments seemed to do the trick as a flash survey from ICM for The Guardian found that voters thought he had performed the best on the night, putting the prime minister above Miliband (38%) and Clegg (19%).
Cameron won the event, according to a snap poll from ICM for The Guardian newspaper.
CAMERON WINS ICM/Guardian Cameron - 44% Miliband - 38% Clegg - 19% http://t.co/SdW8qsQALe
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 30, 2015
Natalie Bennett wasn't part of tonight's event but the Greens were quick to send over her thoughts. This is what they emailed us as soon as the show had finished.
"Tonight's show was a poor cousin to the previous debates. Not only were no women involved, but the range of the discussion was incredibly limited," Bennett said.
"No one was offering genuine alternative to the failed policy of austerity, and no one was truly standing up the vicious rhetoric on immigration that has infected political debate in this country."
If the Liberal Democrats don't get into power after the general election, Clegg said he will plan to stay on as leader.
Clegg says he will stay on as Lib Dem leader of the party doesn't get into power #bbcqt https://t.co/PnyFwBjjrK
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 30, 2015
The questions have now switched to the areas of immigration and the EU. The Liberal Democrat leader wants the UK to stay within the political and economic group, but Clegg admitted that he had problems about migrants being able to claim benefits in the UK.
Clegg on EU migration: Freedom of movement is not freedom to claim. It's also a two-way street -- Britons benefit elsewhere in EU. #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
And on a vote of the UK's membership of the EU.
Clegg: I remain of the view that we should have a referendum on EU when and if new powers are given to Brussels. Only then. #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
'Charming. No I don't [have plans for a new job],' says Clegg #bbcqt https://t.co/W69b46dW6M
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 30, 2015
Nick Clegg has argued that the "real question" for the electorate at the general election is who goes into Number 10 with Ed Miliband or David Cameron after 7 May.
He argued that the Liberal Democrats would stop a "lurch to the left or right" and warned of Alex Salmond teaming up with Miliband and Nigel Farage making a deal with Cameron.
Clegg stressed that he would not go into government unless Labour or the Tories would promise to increase the education budget in England.
Clegg: Lib Dems will not going into any coalition or govt unless parties pledge to increase education budget. #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
Liberal Democrat leader Nick Clegg is now on. The deputy prime minister, who faces a tough fight to win Sheffield Hallam again, was asked about his 2010 tuition fee pledge.
Clegg up now. Q: Tuition fees destroyed your reputation. How can we now trust anything you say? #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
Clegg: Nice easy one to start... Made a mistake. Apologised. But have delivered on other things, i.e. income tax cut for lowest paid. #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
Miliband ends on a high as the debate switched to the issue of trust and politicians.
Big clap from audience as Miliband says he wants to overdeliver #bbcqt https://t.co/eXzaygeTuG
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 30, 2015
Miliband stressed that he believes in a welfare system that "encourages responsibility". He also claimed that a Labour government would guarantee unemployed young people would take a job or lose their benefits.
When asked where the jobs would come from, Miliband said a "proper" industrial policy was needed alongside a cut to business rates.
Q: How will you undo the adult further education cuts? Mili: I can't promise to reverse cuts, but I can promise to protect budget. #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
The Labour leader has now been quizzed about the possibility of a deal between his party and the SNP in the event of a hung parliament after 7 May.
Mili: Let me be clear, there'll be no deal with the SNP. There'll be no Lab govt if it means deals or coalition with the SNP. #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
Miliband emphatic on not doing a deal with the SNP. Says would rather not have a Labour government than do a deal with SNP. #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
The BBC Question Time got fiery after Miliband said he didn't think the last Labour government overspend before they were kicked out of office in 2010. He argued that the party now has a plan to "balance the books", whereas the Tories want to double their cuts.
Miliband faced another hostile question after he said Labour didn't overspend in power #bbcqt https://t.co/EB8XfaxqNL
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 30, 2015
Now Labour leader Ed Miliband is up. He faced a baptism of fire over Labour's economic record in government.
Audience member blasts Miliband for apparently not answering her question #bbcqt https://t.co/oxhzauUmhi
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 30, 2015
Mili says Balls deadly serious about economy and clearing the deficit, as well as improving things for businesses. #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
Cameron has revealed that a referendum on the UK's membership of the EU is a "red line" for him when it comes to coalition government negotiations.
The promise is a clear message to voters and Liberal Democrat leader Nick Clegg with just a week to go before the election.
And that's it for Cameron. Confident performance, no blunders, handled Qs well. But nothing to get excited about either. #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
Things are getting a bit informal.
'Hi David, you alright mate?' #bbcqt https://t.co/nGVGHT4t3c
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 30, 2015
Cameron has restated his promise to bring net migration to the UK to tens of thousands after official figures from the ONS showed that he missed his 2010 target.
Q: If we stay in EU how can you control immigration?
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
Cam: We can control it from outside EU by clamping down on things like bogus colleges etc. From in EU, tighten migrant benefit rules. #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
Audience member tells Cameron he's wrong over the NHS #bbcqt https://t.co/mA6vngq02O
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 30, 2015
The public are now grilling the prime minister over the NHS. Cameron said his government have overseen a "recovery job", including 7,000 more nurses, millions more operations a year and 9,000 more doctors.
Q: Why don't voters trust your party with NHS? Cam: All I can say is what I believe. Talks about quality NHS care for late son Ivan. #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
Cameron defended his promise to legislate against tax rises over the next parliament after some tough questions from the audience. The Tory leader said he wants to make sure people keep more of their cash and "stop taxing poor people".
The question and audience session with Cameron is becoming increasing hostile.
Audience member shouts "zero hours contracts". Cam says just 1 in 50 new jobs are zero hours. #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
Former Labour Treasury secretary Liam Byrne once left a note to the next government after Gordon Brown lost the 2010 General Election. It said there was no money left for Cameron's administration to spend.
Cameron gets Liam Byrne's infamous 'no money' note out #bbcqt https://t.co/pMUYjK1qWC
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 30, 2015
The discussion has swiftly switched to a debate about benefits and youth unemployment.
Q: What about young people with no support network? Won't housing benefit cut for under-25s put them on the streets? #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
Cam: We'd have special provision to help those young people who had nowhere else to live. And get more young people into work. #bbcqt
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
The first question to Cameron is on the reports that the Tories are planning to cut child tax credits if they gain power after the general election. The prime minister stressed that he wouldn't make such a move and said he wanted to end the "rumours".
Cameron denies reports about the Tory's plan to cut child benefit #bbcqt https://t.co/teZiOvVUp0
— Ian Silvera (@ianjsilvera) April 30, 2015
Cameron goes into #bbcqt off the back of a poll that puts Tories five points ahead of Labour http://t.co/j2yvaBMxHd pic.twitter.com/ddNmBnwLRH
— IBTimesUK Politics (@IBTUKPolitics) April 30, 2015
Here's the line-up:
1. David Cameron
2. Ed Miliband
3. Nick Clegg
In the meantime, here's a shocking fact from homelessness charity Shelter.
Tonight's @BBCOne #bbcqt is being held in Leeds, where it takes an average of 11 years to save for a first home. pic.twitter.com/0M7lqmMgiH
— Shelter (@Shelter) April 30, 2015
Dimbleby shows off invisible selfie stick.
Preparations are underway for tonight's #GE2015 @bbcquestiontime special in Leeds. Join us at 8pm on BBC One. #bbcqt pic.twitter.com/9dvq457Vya
— BBC Question Time (@bbcquestiontime) April 30, 2015
Back in 2005, a fresher faced Tony Blair was booed as he walked into Question Time's TV special ahead of that year's general election.
Spoilers: the former Labour leader went onto to gain another majority in the House of Commons with just over 35% of the vote. Skip to 58:00 for the fun.
© Copyright IBTimes 2024. All rights reserved.