Angry librarians breathe fire after columnist suggests closing public libraries
Andre Walker claimed that no one goes to public libraries and suggested they be closed and the books given to schools.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ae79e/ae79eb9f08d76fc255350a9d435c9ee25d61b46d" alt="Books, Library"
The person leaving dog ears in books and talking loudly on his phone is no longer the most disliked person in the library world. It is Andre Walker.
The New York Observer columnist recently trigged the wrath of the 'guardians of books' when he suggested that all public libraries should be closed since nobody goes to them anymore. He added that the books should then be given to school-run libraries instead.
While Walker is known for making inflammatory statements meant to rile people up, the reading community was not willing to take this one lying down. The comment immediately triggered a wave of angry responses from librarians, book-lovers, teachers and students alike.
"School librarian here," one woman from Ann Arbor, Michigan commented. "We don't want the public library's collection. It's for a broad audience. Ours is specialised. We have diff[erent] roles."
Nobody goes to libraries anymore. Close the public ones and put the books in schools. https://t.co/Cimy1V81n5
— Andre Walker (@andrejpwalker) October 22, 2017
This is bad. How do you anger Librarians! https://t.co/EqSDNiC6jL
— Andre Walker (@andrejpwalker) October 23, 2017
I know this makes Librarians angry but shutting libraries and putting the books into schools would be an absolute good. https://t.co/AEy4X0iAAx
— Andre Walker (@andrejpwalker) October 24, 2017
Librarians are like French teachers. These jobs exist in order to pay the wages of sad people who can't get proper work.
— Andre Walker (@andrejpwalker) October 24, 2017
Another Twitter user described it as utter rubbish. "People of all ages use our libraries. Older people & low income often can't afford devices and prefer actual books," she wrote.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/93cb6/93cb6d22b148a8398e7400dc143f2d065093d891" alt="Library"
One teacher explained how she uses the library to meet students and homeless teens. "What a lifesaver it is for my homeless teens. It's safe, warm & they can feel 'normal'," she wrote and was followed up by a woman who shared her own experience of using the space as place of refuge.
"Libraries saved me when I was homeless. Had a safe space to cool off/get warm and look for jobs, attempt to sign up for services," she commented.
He thinks you can avoid literature by closing libraries. He doesnât realise intelligent people LIKE to read. Also, he has a punchable face.
— Miserable Swine (@wiltybanter) October 24, 2017
Come now, there's no need to get perso...hmm, I see what you mean. pic.twitter.com/1jRWWL7Zow
— Hawklips Hoolihan (@NealBrophy) October 24, 2017
OH HELL NO! HOLD MY EARRINGS! https://t.co/s3WzpFy4cy
— KCMO Public Library (@KCLibrary) October 24, 2017
One man in particular, describing himself as the "angriest librarian" (@HalpernAlex) went on a profanity-riddled rant against Walker while speaking up for these public spaces.
As conservatives have taken over state and local governments, and the NO MORE TAXES crowd has gotten their way, public space has decreased.
— TheAngriestLibrarian (@HalpernAlex) October 23, 2017
That means is that there are a lot fewer free, public gathering places in America anymore. What's one? The motherfucking public library.
— TheAngriestLibrarian (@HalpernAlex) October 23, 2017
If you, like this jackalope, think libraries are just warehouses for books, you are sorely and embarrassingly mistaken. Sorely.
— TheAngriestLibrarian (@HalpernAlex) October 23, 2017
In addition to meeting a community's need for educational and recreational materials, PARTICULARLY FOR YOUNG FAMILIES...
— TheAngriestLibrarian (@HalpernAlex) October 23, 2017
public libraries are evolving to meet the demands of the 21st Century, unlike the neanderthal who sparked this thread.
— TheAngriestLibrarian (@HalpernAlex) October 23, 2017
Books? Books make up a RAPIDLY decreasing percentage of a library's budget. You want to check out technology? get a library card.
— TheAngriestLibrarian (@HalpernAlex) October 23, 2017
You need internet access because you are one of the WAY TOO MANY underserved and marginalized persons in America? Go to the library.
— TheAngriestLibrarian (@HalpernAlex) October 23, 2017
You need a safe place to learn about yourself, LGBT teen? Come to the library. You need to learn English to get a job? Come to the library.
— TheAngriestLibrarian (@HalpernAlex) October 23, 2017
You need to close libraries because you have no idea what the fuck they do? Stay the fuck home and shut your mouth.
— TheAngriestLibrarian (@HalpernAlex) October 23, 2017
Just kidding, everyone is welcome at the library, even the backwards thinking simpletons who want to cut our budgets.
— TheAngriestLibrarian (@HalpernAlex) October 23, 2017
Over 110,000 comments later, Walker finally ceded his argument. "Your sheer numbers have proved the point that libraries aren't as unpopular as I believed this morning. Please stop replying," he wrote. "I surrender."
Dear #Library users, I surrender! pic.twitter.com/1F0cog6xo0
— Andre Walker (@andrejpwalker) October 24, 2017